Monday, February 20, 2017

al-Baqarah: The Disputed Murder and the Yellow Cow.


The 2nd chapter of the Holy Qur'an is named al-Baqarah. This is so named because in this chapter God describes an incident that happened at the time of Prophet Moses. Citing this incident, Prophet Muhammad warn his Sahaba as-

[On the authority of Abu Hurairah]: I heard Rasulullah say: "What I have forbidden to you, avoid; what I have ordered you [to do], do as much of it as you can. It was only their excessive questioning and their disagreeing with their Prophets that destroyed those who were before you." -[Bukhari, Muslim, Nawawi].

The detailed story as follows-
Among the children of Israel, there was a rich man, who had a beautiful daughter. The man's heir was his nephew- a vagabond. The nephew wanted to marry his cousin-sister, but his uncle denied it. So the nephew went to Pythia and seek her advice. The Pythia told him- "Your uncle will not die soon, so if you want to marry her, you have to kill your uncle." She also instructs him on how to kill and how to be safe from the accusation of murder.

One day, the rich man was found dead near the residential area of a tribe of Bani Israel. There were many speculations regarding the motive of the murder, but nobody could figure out whodunnit.

The relatives of the rich man including his nephew started searching for the murderer, but they still could not trace him. It was a law, that if anyone was killed near a city and the murderer would not be traced, then the city dweller shall pay the blood money. With this law, the nephew demanded the blood money to the nearby tribe's men. But they denied it, saying: "We are not the murderer." they trying to get rid of the evidence.

Killing someone among the Israelites was something extremely horrible. So, the incident that grew a harsh discord became into a harsh argument that made a war situation between the two tribes of the Israelis. And then a wise man said to them, "Why you will kill each other when a Prophet of God among you? Go to him, maybe he will solve this with the help of God."

So both parties came to Moses and appealed to him to resolve the dispute. The nephew of the victim demanded revenge, but his claims have been turned down due to the lack of witnesses. On the other hand, before Moses all parties were equal. And still, there was no evidence for issuing a verdict on the matter and also by that time the possibility of resolving a dispute by making the parties give an oath has not been revealed yet. However, Moses takes some time, then he told them to slaughter a cow.

The Jews thought that he is making fun of them as they always do that to Moses, Actually, they love to do that, but fun with them at this time, when the matter was so serious!! The resentment boiled over: "We brought to you a dead man and you say that we should slay a cow? Are you mocking us? What does the cow have to do with that?” 

They thought that the decision of God did not correspond with their concern. How could they comprehend the wisdom concealed in that decision? Or maybe they confronted Moses not trusting his words. However, Moses replied- "God forbid that I should be among the foolish!" he insisted, “I am quite serious, this is the will of God.” 
Now they believed that the order was serious, so, they politely asked him to tell God to be more specific. And Moses clarified, "It should be a handsome yellow cow."

There are plenty of handsome yellow cows around, pick one and sacrifice. But no, the Jews showed their nature again, as they so often are. So they want Moses to tell God to tell him to tell them what specific kind of cow He wants for a sacrifice.  Because all cows look the same to them.

Yellow Heifer
Is it true that the Jews want to solve this case? It seems to, Then why are they became whine now? So God wanted to treat them accordingly.

Woh! You want to solve something that is out of your knowledge. Ok, boys be ready to pay its price. It is because, free things never be valued by anyone, by the way, do you ever find someone who thanks God for Sunlight, Moonlight, Water, Air, or the Soil that keeps people alive?

So God comes back with the list of everything that he wants this special cow to be. And this time, it is too demanding and too picky that perfectly fitted for the whiny Jews.  Then when they find that the details of the cows are already given and they have nothing to ask, they said to Moses, “Now you have brought us the truth.” 

In the Qur'an, the cow story went down, as thus- And when ye slew a man and disagreed concerning it and Allah brought forth that which ye were hiding. -'[2:72]

When Moses said to his people: “God demands that you sacrifice a cow,”
They said: “Are you making fun of us?”
And he said: “God forbid that I be of the ignorant.”
“Call on your Lord for us,” they said, “that He might inform us what kind she should be.” 
“Neither old nor young says God, but of age in between,” answered Moses. “So do as you are bid.”
“Call on your Lord,” they said, “to tell us the color of the cow.”
“God says,” answered Moses, “a fawn-colored cow, rich yellow, well pleasing to the eye.”
“Call on your Lord,” they said, “to name its variety, as cows are all alike to us. If God wills we shall be guided aright.”
And Moses said: “He says it’s a cow unyoked, nor worn out by ploughing or watering the fields, one in good shape with no mark or blemish.” 
“Now have you brought us the truth,” they said; -[2:67-71]

Then the Jews went out in search of such a cow. The only one that matched the description was the one owned by the orphaned youth. They met him on the way and asked the price for which he would sell his cow. He told them he would have to consult his mother first, so they accompanied him to his house and offered her three gold coins. She refused their offer, saying that the cow was worth much more.

They went on increasing their offer and the mother kept on refusing. Finally, they urged the son not to speak to his mother and to be reasonable. He told them: "I will not sell the cow without my mother's approval, even if you offered me its skin filled with gold!"

On hearing this, his mother smiled and said: "Let that be the price: its skin filled with gold."
They realized that no other cow would do; they had to have it at any price. They agreed to buy the cow and promised to pay it's skin filled with gold.

They brought the cow to Moses and we already said that they believed Moses, after all those mind games that they played going back and forth with their Lord. No more whining now, they just do it- sacrificed the cow. Then God commanded that the victim should be touched by a part of the cow’s body- a chunk of beef.

"What happened then?"
Wow, just wow.  Imagine if all of this actually happened. You’d have all these Jews slapping a corpse with bloody chunks of beef, but those [since there is no God -those atheists may be thought this] believe Moses is not from God, and since people do not come back from the dead, nothing to happen. So they are now ready to do it.

"Then?"
Oh, let the Jews take a chunk of beef and slap the dead again and again. Wahoo, yes, they just do it and then it happened.
"What happened?"
The miracle, yes the miracle happened, the dead guy comes back to life as soon as the piece of beef touches him. Then he told the Jews who was the guy that killed him. Qur'an says- And We said: Smite him with some of it. Thus Allah bringeth the dead to life and showeth you His portents so that ye may understand. -'[2:73]

Now, we will see, what the Jewish sacred books said to this special "Yellow Heifer". According to Jewish tradition, a "Red Heifer" [The Yellow Cow, is basically the same as the Red Cow of the Bible. The Jew make it red or God just forgot the color? we do not know what the Jew would comment about this.] is a female cow that is three years of age with a particular reddish hue and cannot have even two hairs of any other color. It cannot be used for any type of labor and must be blemish free. The biblical commandment regarding the Red Heifer can be found in the Book of Numbers and is considered as the only antidote to the state of impurity brought on by death.

“The emergence of the Red Heifer is not some mystical miracle,” elucidated Rabbi Richman. “It is a practical development alongside Torah knowledge and science.”

The Red Heifer (Hebrew: פָרָ֨ה אֲדֻמָּ֜ה‎‎; para adumma), also known as the red cow, was a cow brought to the priests as a sacrifice according to the Hebrew Bible, and its ashes were used for the ritual purification of Tum'at HaMet ("the impurity of the dead"), that is, an Israelite who had come into contact with a corpse.

"Then?"
Then what? Do you think the dead comes back to life and began to live with his family again?
No, a dead can't eat, drink or breathe. The Truth is, as Moses and Jesus are both human, they have no power to do it, but as a prophet, God gave them a temporary power to show a Sign in favor of God only to establish God's Essence. This is the cause- the Israelis died again and none of the scriptures let you know what happened to "Lazarus" after coming back to life [Though you will find some stupid, who will say Lazarus ended his second earthly life at Cyprus in 63 CE]. Only God Possesses this Power [see below the incident of 70 Israelis]. Thus, in this case, we can say that the dead back to life temporarily only to reveal the killer. Actually, he only pronounced: “I was killed by my nephew.” something like this, and then the dead man became silent again.

"Then?"
Then the story goes its own way. The truth showed up. And as the killer was known by the clue that could not be denied because it is a truthful testimony that God made it as He makes the non-living things speak to show the truth of the hands of His prophet, so what the Jews should do? They should kiss the killer?

No, a cold-blooded murderer has no right to live. Murdering a human in cool blood is the greatest crime in the eyes of God, This crime will make a man a huge loser in the hereafter even if you find him a Mumim in his earthly life.

Thus God prescribe to kill the murderer publicly in front of God's house after prayer, so that people may not hate the killer but understand the works of Satan, who successfully influenced the man to kill the victim and made him looser in both the world- a hateful punishment in this world and a promise of more hateful punishment in the hereafter.

So, the Jews killed the man. And thus they got rid of a great anarchy which they never did see before, This is what God is saying: "Thus God bringeth the dead to life and showeth you His portents so that ye may understand." 
And from then all nephews lost their inheritance from their uncle.

When pondering over the miracles of God, one is caught in admiration. The mysteries of the world cannot be fully disclosed by anybody but God. Hasn’t there been another way to find out who the murderer was? Was the only way to do that to make a dead man speak? Could a slaughtered cow make a dead man alive by itself? No, the Creator of Heaven and Earth was the real cause for that and it happened solely according to His will.

Look, how obeying the will of God makes a piece of meat of a slaughtered animal capable of performing such things! How can one ignore that it was God’s will that made the slaughtered cow the means of making the dead man speak?

If one comprehends that one should also recognize that the cow was nothing more than a means. The cow by itself cannot be regarded as a deity. Those who worship God should know Him and not confuse the means with Him Who causes it to come into being. To comprehend this simple truth, one does not have to possess great wisdom and knowledge.

NB: You may read the following article for more entertainment-- The Blessed Cow of the Children of Israel  

The End.
Not Yet Verified.

# "Oh Bro, the Jews Killed a Man Because He was Certified by a Dead Man?"
@ I said, "We already said in our article that when the truth showed up and the killer was known by the clue that could not be denied because it is a truthful testimony that God made it as He makes the non-living things speak to show the truth of the hands of His prophet, then who to disagree? Do you not understand that was a Prophetic era, not an era of Science and Technology like our days.

And, why you are astonished by this?
Ahmed Ali, who wrote a translation of the Holy Qur'an, is not he a total pussy? We are not going to explain here how he sneaks things in with parentheses to skew the text one way or another. Why we? Do you not see, how he tried to justify that entire one woman is equal to half a man thing by saying it’s because women suck in business matters?

Well, he does again, folks. This is his version of the same Quranic verses that we use above:

"Remember when you killed a man and blamed each other for the deed, God brought to light what you concealed. We had pronounced already: “Slay (the murderer) for (taking a life).” Thus God preserves life from death and shows you His signs that you may understand."- [2:72-73]

So, why blame Jews?

# "Bro, What is the Significance of This Story?"
I said, This story not teaches us that God can perform Miracles. It just shows us the nature of Jews and understanding God's Essence.

"A Leopard does not change its Spots."
Similarly, Jews can't change their nature. Thus it follows- "Dealing with Jews bears no fruits." And surely, it will be extremely tiresome to make any kind of negotiation with them. They made Moses cry his heart out "May God makes their Hearts Bleed."
"Cool bro,"
Sure, I am not in a bad temper.

Actually, here, the above story is- Someone among the Jews, killed a Jew and then tricks with God's law that makes a war situation between two tribes of Israelis. And when they failed to figure out whodunnit, they came to Moses to solve the case ie. they came to him to know, who the killer is. And, Moses said to them, “God demands that you sacrifice a cow,”

Now, it's a God's order, so, what are you expect from a nation those are God's chosen people? They at once ready to do it, is not it?
But, no! It's Jew- a thing, And because of their stubbornness, they start negotiating.
“Call on your Lord for us,” they said, “that He might inform us what kind she should be.”
So, Moses asked his Lord another time and came back to them with the answer, “Neither old nor young, says God, but of age in between,” he continued. “So, do as you are bid.”

These words are quite clear, the cow required is neither too old nor too young but middling between the two. So, it was obligatory on their part to sly a cow that fitted this description. But they were Jews, who become habituated to disobey God's order- that is they are a habitual transgressor.

"Habitual Transgressor?"
Look, when Moses went to the mountain Tur [a mountain in the Arabian desert] to bring the law book of God, the Jews made a golden calf, as their god and guider and worshiped. Do you ever find any cows to worship a calf?
"No".
But the Jews did that.

And, when Moses present the book of God to them, they said, "O, Moses, how do we know that it is from God? It may possible that you have written that book but telling us that it's from God?"
He said, "O my people, why do you harm me while you certainly know that I am the Messenger of God to you?"
They said, "We can't take this as a book of God without any proof, Surely, we never do such unless otherwise God Himself tells us that it is His book."
Moses thought it would be a messy situation if he brought six hundred thousand people to that holy place, so he said, "Then, select your leader, who shall be the witness."

They select 70 [six from each tribe] men and Moses and Aron brought them to the place as instructed by God. And, He speaks to them. His "Ten Commandments" echoed equally from each side. The Jews heard this Voice, which was clear and loud. And their eyes move around them in each direction but they seeth nothing- no one. So they said to Moses, "Show us Allah outright," -[4:153]

No one can see God with their eyes as He is not living in our world. So, when they said, "O Moses, we will never believe you until we see Allah outright";
"What?!"
Yeah, this is why we called them transgressors.
"Then?"
Then, a thunderbolt took them while they were looking on.

When Moses came back to his sense, he found them dead. He cried to his Lord, "My Lord, if You had willed, You could have destroyed them before and me [as well]. Would You destroy us for what the foolish among us have done? This is not but Your trial by which You send astray whom You will and guide whom You will. You are our Protector, so forgive us and have mercy upon us, and You are the best of forgivers. And decree for us in this world [that which is] good and [also] in the Hereafter; indeed, we have turned back to You." 
[God] said, "My punishment - I afflict with it whom I will, but My mercy encompasses all things." So I will decree it [especially] for those who fear Me and give zakah and those who believe in Our verses -[7:155-56]

"And, what did God do then?"
That is what Qur'an says- Then We revived you after your death that perhaps you would be grateful. -[2:56]
Thus, when they return, said, "What Moses said is true, surely it is His Book." Yet the situation improved nothing, though those 70 men tried their best to convince them. The Jews, yeah, they were still arrogant. And for the 1st time in the history of mankind, they trick to play with God's law.

Korah [Qarun in the Qur'an]- a Levite, arguing that it is impossible to endure laws instituted by Moses. He said, "O you Jew! Don’t you see those laws that Moses made in the name of God, shall rich the priests only? And will make all of us in a few years to beg to the door of Aaron, the Priest? He then explains the laws of Moses with the following parable [made by cut-pasting some of God's laws]:

"A widow, the mother of two young daughters, had a field. When she came to plow it, Moses told her not to plow it with an ox and an ass together -(Deut. 22:10); when she came to sow it, Moses told her not to sow it with mingled seeds -(Lev. 19:19). At the time of harvest, she had to leave unreaped the parts of the field prescribed by the Law -(Lev. 23:22), while from the harvested grain she had to give the priest the share due to him. -(Lev. 23:10)


The woman sold the field and with the proceeds bought two sheep. But the first-born of these she was obliged to give to Aaron the priest, and at the time of shearing he required the first of the fleece also -(Deut. 18:4). The widow said: 'I can not bear this man's demands any longer. It will be better for me to slaughter the sheep and eat them.' But Aaron came for the shoulder, the two cheeks, and the maw -(ib. verse 3). The widow then vehemently cried out: 'If thou persistest in thy demand, I declare them devoted to the Lord.'


Aaron replied: 'In that case, the whole belongs to me' -(Num. 18:14), whereupon he took away the meat, leaving the widow and her two daughters wholly unprovided for" -(Num. R. 18:2-3; Tan., Korah, 4-6).


"Now, O my people!", Korah said, "Do you want to believe these laws that will make you a dime-less beggar within a few years like the widow, but riches Aaron, the Priest, are from God?
No, surely not, Moses himself has written those for you, O my people! they want to steal your wealth only to make themselves wealthiest".

So, when Moses ordered the Israelis to take the book, they said, "O Moses! “We can't take the book.”
Moses said, "Do you want to say that the book is not from God after 70 of your leader certify and bear witness that it is from God?"
They said, “We can't take the book. as its laws are difficult to obey."
They demand to change the scripture.

What should God do?
He Himself talked to them [so that they shall be judged in future by other people], told them, "Take what We have given you with determination and listen."
600,000 [it is 603,550 as per Numbers 1:46; and we need not verify these nos. logically, as it is not a factor here] Israelis hear these words of God with their own ear. And, what do you expect from a situation like this?
"Yet, only a few of them believe!"
No, not so. They all replied, "We hear and we disobey."

Now, what is appropriate for God to do with them? Is there anything left for Him that He may do for His chosen people except saying, "Take it, O My People or My Wrath may perish you, as We perish them before you, those were Transgressor,"
"Sure."
Now, say, God killed them all, then, would you expect anyone among the human, who is wise [as we may not consider those who are stupid's] will blame God in the future or on the day of Judgement?
"No."
You are wrong. You may not find anyone in this world among humans because, they are unable to use 100% of their brain, but in the future, some supercomputers will show different when it will analyze this type of situation. Consider a case that it showed a result that is contradictory, say, either a pause or answered both "yes" and "no" [IT professionals may understand this "TEST"], even, you will find some human another way blaming God in the day of Judgement when their brain will work 100% for memorizing all that they have done in their earthly life, will surely ask God, "You are God, why not You did something at that time with your Godly power to correct us?"

So, an Ethical God, Who is Wisest, Most Merciful, can not leave a job that may lead a question towards Him ever, even when human shall use their 100% brain. Thus, God did a thing that is not a part of human function but only His Power [time-based]. He ordered the angel Gabriel to raise the mountain over them. Qur'an says “And when We raised the mountain above them as if it was a dark cloud and they were certain that it would fall upon them, [and Allah said], "Take what We have given you with determination and remember what is in it that you might fear Allah ." -(7:171)
Now, we will enquire what the Jews did in that situation.

At that time, the Jews found themselves in a critical position that they never thought of, this time they feared and realized without the tiniest doubt that the mountain going to put them to an end. At that point, at the edge of death and life, they gave "WORDS" to their Lord that they will obey Him and His laws.

But later history says the exact opposite. We find them again to trick with God's law. It was a Jewish tradition of the Sabbath that they are not allowed to work or do business on the Sabbath day ie. Saturday. So, they began to play tricks. On the Sabbath day, they put their net in the water but catch the fish the next day. By doing this, they thought they were bypassing God's law. According to ibn Kathir, "They began using deceitful means to avoid honoring the Sabbath by placing nets, ropes, and artificial pools of water for the purpose of fishing before the Sabbath. When the fish came in abundance on Saturday as usual, they were caught in the ropes and nets for the rest of Saturday. During the night, the Jews collected the fish after the Sabbath ended."

"What is, that God said to them?"
He punished them. Qur'an says,- So when they were insolent about that which they had been forbidden, We said to them, "Be apes, despised."-[7:166]
"What?!"
Why not? You prohibit something for somebody and they are disobeying you again and again. Is this not the nature of mad and monkey?
"Yeah."
But mads cannot be considered punishable, even they are not capable of understanding punishment. So? Be Apes with a human brain!
"O, my God! It's severe in nature."
Yah!
"But you said Monkey."
Oh yeah, and then I thought Monkey may not fit with a human. Do they fit?
"I dunno. Leave that, and tell me, exactly what is said in the Qur'an in this regard?"
This is what Qur'an said, "Ask them concerning the town standing close by the sea. Behold! they transgressed in the matter of the Sabbath. For on the day of their Sabbath, their fish did come to them, openly holding up their heads, but on the day they had no Sabbath, they came not: thus did We make a trial of them, for they were given to transgression." -[7:163]

So, what do you say? If you replace Jews with the worst animal, will they do that? This is the reason that some people believe- Jews possess inherently evil traits, they are treacherous, corrupt, deceitful, and unfaithful by nature. Their “attributes” and traditions are presented by the scriptures as unchangeable nature. However, what we are telling- the cow story of  the Qur'an___

After knowing what kind the cow should be, they proceeded as “Call on your Lord,” they said, “to tell us the color of the cow.”

This is most strange, the color of the cows! No, we would not resort to people rather we should consult with cows in this matter, "O cows, is it acceptable? Is it sound? What is the value that lurks behind knowing the color of a cow?"
The cows are not answering. How could they? So it's better we asked ourselves.
Is not all cows are the same in the sight of everyone? Are we ever shown any interest in the color of a cow? If not, then what is the most urgent need that makes Moses go to God to ask Him about the color of the cow?

Moreover, look at the way they addressed- “Call on your Lord,”  It is as if He is the Lord of Moses only and not theirs. Is there anything that could be more haughty or disobedient than this? In spite of being hot-tempered, the patient and generous Moses went on to get answers from God to their useless questions.
“God says,” answered Moses, “a fawn-colored cow, rich yellow, well pleasing to the eye.”

What do you think, the matter is over now? Oh no! there are still some disputes, the Jews told Moses, “Call on your Lord,” they continued, “to name its variety, as cows are all alike to us. If God wills we shall be guided aright.”

Wow! After all that was said and all the previous descriptions, still, the Jews did not know what kind of cow that should be! How amazing! Ha, Ha, Ha, my side is about to burst, my belly is about to explode. Hah, Hah, Hah. Surely. if they were cows, they would not behave in the same way.

Now, tell me, what is appropriate for God to treat these Jews?
"Surely, the treat should be transcendent the limit of logic, usual thinking, and behavior."
Yah! And this is the cause that God said, "Smite him with some of it."

And when they did that, the dead comes back to life. Then they asked him about his killer and he told them who was the guy that killed him. This is what God reminds us- "Thus Allah bringeth the dead to life and showeth you His portents so that ye may understand." -[2:73]

Now, o my friend, you asked me- what is the significance of this story?
Then what I have to say, do you really understand anything from this story?
"Not actually."
Ok leave it, we will explain.

The Jews do not obey God but repeatedly trick with His laws to gain themselves. This story tells us such things.

Killing humans is prohibited in Jewish law, yet a Jew killed a man to have his daughter and his Wealth and then tricked to have blood money too.
Look! What a perception! Wow... !! Triple gain from one business? Nah, I like Jews.
"Me too."
What!?
"Because they do not know how to lose in Business. They engaged themselves in Business if profitable even when that is prohibited. You know,  they raise pigs!"
No. I dunno, really. I only know they lend money [with interest] for business. However, what we are telling- This intelligent man, brought the dead to his neighbor tribesmen area so that he may accuse them of murder and may demand the blood money according to the laws of God. So, what God shall do?
He wanted to teach them this-

"O Jews! you are alive, and your brains are still working, yet you are not capable to find the truth from a dead man, while you are eager to know the color of the cows from your Lord! 
O Jews! An animal that is lower grade than you, and even when it is dead, shall able to bring out the truth from a dead man if God wishes." 

Now, whatever may be the situation, will a Jew ever be able to blame God?

"No"
You are wrong again, it is because you forget humans are created as free-willed. Thus, they surely will lie even at that time when they shall stand in front of their Lord.
Consider that situation.

The Jews and Christians denied Muhammad in the day of judgment standing in front of their Lord. Do you think what they are doing! The man who should be known to every creature of God, yet a portion of a human, the best of His creation do not know him. And they complained to their Lord God against their Prophets, those are God's representatives, that they didn't perform their jobs well, they didn't do what they should have to do. Thus because of their fault "the Messiah to Mankind" is unknown to them.
"What a lie! Imposing falsehood on Prophets!"
Yeah, this would be the case. However, what should be perfect for God to do in that situation?
He Smiles, His Gage directly to Moses and then to Jesus.

RECALL!
And they recalled the covenant God made with them before sending the human to the earth. "And when Allah took a covenant from the Prophets: 'This is the Book and the Wisdom which I have given you. But should a Prophet come to you confirming that which is already with you, you shall believe in him and shall help him. So saying, Allah asked: 'Do you agree and accept to take up the "BURDEN of the covenant"?' 
They answered: 'We agree,' 
He said: 'Then bear witness, and I will be with you among the witness. -[Qur'an, 3:81]

Do you consider the mental condition of the prophets at that time?
Moses shaking -the autistic man fails to utter a single word.
"SHIT!"

So God will say to Jesus, "O Son of Mary," He continued "What do you say? Do you not bear witness? Do you not preach to them Gospel?"
Jesus will say exactly what is written in the Qur'an. ie. he will say, "I said to them", taking a breath he continued, "O children of Israel, indeed I am the Messenger of Allah to you confirming what came before me of the Torah and bringing good tidings of a messenger to come after me, whose name is Ahmad." -[Qur'an 61: 6].

God will say, 'O Jesus son of Mary, did you say to people, 'Take me and my mother as two gods instead of God,?' 
He will reply, 'Glory be to You - it Was not for me to say what I had no right to say! If I ever said that, then You would certainly know it. You know what is in me, and I do not know what is in You - surely it is only You Who knows what is hidden. I only told them what You commanded me - to, ''Worship God, my Lord, and your Lord."' and while I dwelt among them I was a watcher over them, and when You took me up, then You were a Watcher over them - and You watch over everything." -[Qur'an 5: 116-117].

Consider the scene. The Christian Lord God recites verses of the Qur'an in front of the whole of mankind. F...ing Drama.
"SHAME!"

But, Muslims can't let their prophet Moses or Jesus to be ashamed, even when they shall stand in front of their Lord by the Jews or Christians. So, they shall shout loudly -"LIARS! ALL THE JEWS AND CHRISTIANS  ARE F...ING LIARS!"

God, the Most Merciful, Most Fair in Judgement sited in His Throne as Judge of Bani Adam.
He will ask Muslims to prove themselves. And then they shall recite that they memorized in their earthly life.

Now, you may understand why 71% of the Qur'an deals with Myths, ancient histories of the Ad, or the She-Camel of Samud and all those that "Muhammad, the FALSE PROPHET [?]" stolen [?] from the Jewish and Christian Scriptures, which still you may find in their Talmud, or Apocrypha.

But the interesting thing is that the illiterate prophet fails to copy [?] those properly, you will find this True [?] if you carefully investigate this subject. However, those are Muslims, all of them are the same kind of stupid [?] as their Prophet. They still believe in him and his Qur'an with all those Myths and memorize those garbage blindly, in an era when people are going to live on Mars.
Is not this most interesting and amusing?
"Sure,"

Do you find the game?
"What game?"
That Satan made as a producer, where, Jews and Christians are the main role Actors?
"What do you mean?"
I mean, he creates a repulsive force surrounding them to keep them unchanged, which is nothing but a "Mind Game" that may not permit them to change even if they wanted to.
"What!"
Do you not see those Practical Challenges for the Jews or Christians who may want to believe in Qur'an- would face now or shall face in the future?
"O my God!"
Yah! Their own made NEON signs that glowing lights all over the Christian World should laugh at them.
"Wow! I should salute Satan. But, what is not clear to me.."
What?
"That those neon signs actually reads."
It reads- "Muhammad, whom they[Muslims] believed as the Messiah to Mankind, is actually nothing but a PEDOPHILIC, Yet those STUPIDS are not ashamed, but enjoying themselves with a dream to have 70 HURIES in their fucking Heaven."

"Bro, this is an interesting Game, isn't it? Then why should you not sell this plot to some Game Designing Company, when you have some options to earn some "$" ?"

Like JEWS? HAHAHA...

Look, when the Jews replied to God, "We hear and we disobey."
Then Gabriel raised the mountain over them [as we said before]. At that point, they gave "WORDS" to their Lord that they will obey Him and His laws.
And, then God made a Covenant with them which was included with this advice - And believe in what I have sent down, confirming that which is with you [Torah], and be not the first to disbelieve therein, and buy not with My Verses a small price (i.e. getting a small gain by selling My Verses), and fear Me and Me Alone. And do not mix the truth with falsehood or conceal the truth while you know [it]. And establish prayer and give zakah and bow with those who bow [in worship and obedience].- [al-Baqarah, 2:41-42]

And the Jewish Rabbis were in charge of the Torah. Then how it changed? Do you understand why the verse during covenant warns them such in advance? And, what happened later so that a Book of God [Torah] takes today's form? And why Jesus raised his finger to those Rabbis??

"buy not with My Verses a small price (ie. getting a small gain by selling God's Verses), and fear Me and Me Alone. And do not mix the truth with falsehood or conceal the truth while you know [it]." 


And now you tell me to do what the Jews did in their past? HAHAHAA...

NOT BAD ACTUALLY.
HAHAHAA...

Wednesday, February 08, 2017

Pythia: The Oracle of the Delphic Temple of Apollo.


Abu Hena Mostafa Kamal
08 Feb. 2017
"Welcome the tribes of mankind
             Who gather here, and tell them
             Most important of all,
             What [his] will is,"

______________________With this motive, Apollo established his Temple at Delphi. According to myth there were five temples to Apollo, though only two of them exist in historical record.

--The 1st temple was a hut of laurel branches,
--The 2nd was built by the wax of the bees and feathers that eventually sent by Apollo to the land of Hyperboreans,
--The 3rd one was made of bronze was either burned or swallowed by the earth.
--The 4th one was built by Trophonios and Agamedes, the respected architects, and was burned in 548 BCE.
--The 5th temple also damaged by an earthquake in 373 BCE and took fifty years to rebuild, by that time, the Pythia had lost the Power of Prophesy -[Sourvino-Inwood, 231].

The Pythia, commonly known as the Oracle, was actually the High Priestess of the Temple of Apollo at Delphi. The name Pythia is derived from Pytho, which in myth was the original name of Delphi. In etymology, the Greeks derived this name for the place, from the verb, púthein ie. "to rot", which refers to the sickly sweet smell of the decomposition of the body of the monstrous Python after he was slain by Apollo.

The Pythia was widely credited for her prophecies inspired by the spirit of the god Apollo. The Pythian priestess emerged pre-eminent by the end of 7th century BC and would continue her service until the 4th century CE. During this period the Delphic Oracle was the most prestigious and authoritative oracle among the Greeks, and she was without doubt the most powerful woman of the classical world. And the oracle is one of most influential religious institutions of the Greeks.

The Delphic Temple:
It is known that the temple was built upon a spring that was used for purification by the oracle and her attending priests. Plutarch, a priest to the oracle, described the vapors from the spring as “sweetest and most expensive perfumes” -(Littleton, 77).

The ruins of the Temple of Delphi visible today date from the 4th century BC, and are of a peripteral Doric building. It was erected on the remains of an earlier temple, dated to the 6th century BC which itself was erected on the site of a 7th-century BC construction attributed to the architects Trophonios and Agamedes.

The 6th-century BC temple was named the "Temple of Alcmonidae" in tribute to the Athenian family who funded its reconstruction following a fire, which had destroyed the original structure. The new building was a Doric hexastyle temple of 6 by 15 columns. This temple was destroyed in 375 BC by an earthquake. The pediment sculptures are a tribute to Praxias and Androsthenes of Athens. Of a similar proportion to the second temple it retained the 6 by 15 column pattern around the stylobate.

Inside was the adyton, the centre of the Delphic Oracle and seat of Pythia. The temple had the statement "Know thyself", one of the Delphic maxims, carved into it, and the maxims were attributed to Apollo and given through the oracle and/or the Seven Sages of Greece.

The temple survived until AD 390, when the Roman emperor Theodosius-I silenced the oracle by destroying the temple and most of the statues and works of art to remove all traces of Paganism.

Origins of the Oracle:
It is assumed that the Delphic Oracle have been present form 1400 BC to Late Mycenaean times and there is evidence that Apollo took over the shrine from an earlier dedication to Gaia. The account of the origin of the Delphic oracle provided by the Homeric Hymn dedicated to Delphic Apollo [580–570 BCE], describes in detail how Apollo chose his first priests, whom he selected in their "swift ship"; they were "Cretans from Minos' city of Knossos" who were voyaging to sandy Pylos. But Apollo, who had Delphinios as one of his cult epithets, leapt into the ship in the form of a dolphin. Dolphin-Apollo revealed himself to the terrified Cretans, and bade them follow him up to the place where they will have rich offerings. The Cretans danced and followed, singing like the paeans of the Cretans, whose breasts is full of "honey-voiced singing" which divine Muse has placed in their heart. "Paean" seems to be the name by which Apollo was known in Mycenaean times.

There are also many later stories of the origins of the Delphic Oracle. One late explanation, which is related to Diodorus Siculus. He tells of a goat herder named Coretas, who noticed one day that one of his goats, who fell into a crack in the earth, was behaving strangely. On entering the chasm, he found himself filled with a divine presence and could see outside of the present into the past and the future. Excited by his discovery he shared it with nearby villagers. Many started visiting the site to experience the convulsions and inspirational trances, though some were said to disappear into the cleft due to their frenzied state.

A shrine was erected at the site, where people began worshiping in the late Bronze Age, by 1600 BC. As the earth belongs to Goddess Gaia, [Also, unlike tradition where the gender of the priestess or priest is the same as the divinity they served, the oracle was female because she originally served Gaia -(Loyd-Jones, 61)] the villagers chose a young woman as the liaison for the divine inspirations. Eventually she spoke on behalf of gods.

According to earlier myths, the office of the oracle was initially possessed by the daughters of Gaia, Themis and Phoebe. And Gaia appoint a pair of Python as the guardian of the Temple. As the site sacred to Gaia, subsequently, it is believed to be sacred to Poseidon, the god of earthquakes. During 11th to the 9th century BCE, a new god of prophecy, Apollo, allegedly seized the temple and expelled the twin guardian serpents of Gaia, [Apollo slays Python and keeps the oracle for himself to speak to mortals. Hence, the oracle at Delphi is known as Pythia in honor of the killing of Python. -Littleton, 77] whose bodies he wrapped around the caduceus.

Another myths stated that Phoebe or Themis had given the site to Apollo, rationalizing its seizure by priests of the new god, but presumably, having to retain the priestesses of the original oracle because of the long tradition. Apparently Poseidon was mollified by the gift of a new site in Troizen.

Initially, the Pythia was an appropriately clad young virgin, for great emphasis was placed on the Oracle's chastity and purity to be reserved for union with the god Apollo. But later it changed because of the disgrace of a Pythia by a visitor.

Pythia, the Priestess:
Since the first operation of the Oracle of Delphi, it was believed that the god lived within a laurel (his holy plant) and gave oracles for the future with the rustling of the leaves. It was also said that the art of divination had been taught to the god by the three winged sisters of Parnassus, the Thriae, at the time when Apollo was grazing his cattle there. The Thriae used to have a Kliromanteion (oracle by lot) in that area in the past and it is possible that such was the first oracle of Delphi, ie. using the lot (throwing lots in a container and pulling a lot, the color and shape of which were of particular importance).

Pythia, the Oracle of Delphi
Three oracles had successively operated in Delphi –the chthonion using egkoimisi (procedure that involved sleeping in the Holy place, so as to see a revealing dream), the Kliromanteion and finally the Apollonian, with the laurel. But ever since the introduction of the cult of Dionysus at Delphi, the god that brought his fans into ecstasy and madness, the Delphic god Apollo gave Prophesies through Pythia, who also fell into a trance when she received that.

Pythia sat on top of a tall gilded tripod that stood above the opening and would give the prophesy. Previously, Pythia was a virgin, young girl, but ever since Echecrates from Thessaly fell in love, kidnapped and violated the beautiful virgin Pythia, the system changed.

It was reported that-Echecrates the Thessalian, having arrived at the shrine and beheld the virgin who uttered the oracle, became enamoured of her because of her beauty, carried her away and violated her; and that the Delphians because of this deplorable occurrence passed a law that in the future a virgin should no longer prophesy but an elderly woman [older than fifty] as Oracle, who dressed and wore jewelry to resemble a young maiden girl, as a sort of reminder of the prophetess of older times.. According to tradition, Phemonoe was the first Pythia.

During the main period of the Oracle's popularity, as many as three women served as Pythia, two of them a vestige of the triad in shifts and a third as reserved, in case any of them wished a reprieve.

Pythia, in addition to overseeing the oracle, they would also conduct sacrifices at other festivals of Apollo, and had charge of the Pythian games. Earlier arrangements, before the temple became dedicated to Apollo, are not documented.

Pythia's life was shortened through the service of Apollo. The sessions were said to be exhausting. At the end of each period, the Pythia would be like a runner after a race or a dancer after an ecstatic dance, which may have had a physical effect on the health of the Pythia.

Officiants for Oracular Service:
While the temple was dedicated to Apollo, there was probably only one priest of Apollo. But in a later period, several other officiants served the oracle in addition to the Pythia. After 200 BCE at any given time there were two priests of Apollo, who was in charge of the entire sanctuary; Plutarch, who served as a priest during the late first century and early second century CE, gives us the most information about the organization of the oracle at that time.

The other officiants associated with the Oracle are less well known. These are the hosioi ("holy ones") and the prophētai (singular prophētēs). Prophētēs is the origin of the English word "prophet", but a better translation of the Greek word might be "one who speaks on behalf of another person." The prophetai are referred to in literary sources, but their function is unclear; it has been suggested that they interpreted the Pythia's prophecies, or even reformatted her utterances into verse, but it has also been argued that the term prophētēs is a generic reference to any cult officials of the sanctuary, including the Pythia. There were five hosioi, whose responsibilities are unknown, but may have been involved in some manner with the operation of the Oracle.

At times when the Pythia was not available, consultants [literally, “those who seek counsel.”] could obtain guidance by asking simple Yes-or-No questions to the priests. A response was returned through the tossing of colored beans, one color designating "yes," another "no." Little else is known of this practice.

Appointment of Pythia:
Little is known of how the Pythia was chosen, she was probably selected, at the death of her predecessor, from amongst a guild of priestesses of the temple. And were chosen from among the main citizens of Delphi, and appointed for life. And, any type of woman could be chosen to be an oracle. Education, marital status, wealth, and age were no consideration. They were chosen for their aptitude to speak for the god. They required having had a sober life and be of good character.

A married woman, upon assuming her role as Pythia, the priestess, ceased all family responsibilities, marital relations, and individual identity. John Hale reports:

The Pythia was a noble of an aristocratic family, sometimes a peasant, sometimes rich, sometimes poor, sometimes old, sometimes young, sometimes a very lettered and educated woman, other times who could not write her own name. So it seems to have been aptitude rather than any ascribed status that made these women eligible to be Pythias and speak for the god.

In the heyday of the oracle, the Pythia may have been a woman chosen from an influential family, well educated in geography, politics, history, philosophy, and the arts. During later periods, however, uneducated peasant women were chosen for the role, which may explain why the poetic pentameter or hexameter prophecies of the early period, later were made only in prose.

Social Status of Pythia:
The job of a priestess, especially the Pythia, was a respectable career for Greek women. Priestesses enjoyed many liberties and rewards for their social position, such as freedom from taxation, the right to own property and attend public events, a salary and housing provided by the state, a wide range of duties depending on their affiliation, and often gold crowns.

Purification Rites of Pythia:
In the traditions associated with Apollo, the Oracle only gave prophecies during the nine warmest months of each year. During winter months, Apollo was said to have deserted his temple, his place being taken by his divine half-brother Dionysus, whose tomb was also within the temple. It is not known whether the Oracle participated with the Dionysian rites of the Maenads or Thyades in the Korykion cave on Mount Parnassos, although Plutarch informs us that his friend Clea was both a Priestess to Apollo and to the secret rites of Dionysus.

The male priests seem to have had their own ceremonies to the dying and resurrecting god. Apollo was said to return at the beginning of spring, on the 7th day of the month of Bysios, his birthday. This would reiterate the absences of the great goddess Demeter in winter also, which would have been a part of the earliest traditions.

Once a month, thereafter, the oracle would undergo purification rites, including fasting, to ceremonially prepare herself for communications with the god Apollo. On the seventh day of each month, she would be led by two attended oracular priests, with her face veiled in purple. A priest would then declaim:

"Servant of the Delphian Apollo
Go to the Castalian Spring
Wash in its silvery eddies,
And return cleansed to the temple.
Guard your lips from offense
To those who ask for oracles.
Let the God's answer come
Pure from all private fault".

The Pythia would then bathe naked in the Castalian Spring then would drink the holier waters of the Cassotis, which flowed closer to the temple, where a naiad possessing magical powers was said to live. Euripides described this ritual purification ceremony, starting first with the priest I on dancing on the highest point of Mount Parnassus, going about his duties within the temple, and sprinkling the temple floor with holy water. The purification ceremonies always were performed on the seventh day of the month, which was sacred to and associated with the god Apollo.

Then escorted by the Hosioi, an aristocratic council of five, with a crowd of oracular servants, they would arrive at the temple. Pythia would then remove her purple veil. She would wear a short plain white dress.

The Oracle then descended into the adytum ("inaccessible") and mounted her tripod seat, holding laurel leaves and a dish of Kassotis spring water into which she gazed. The tripod on which she seated, acted on behalf of her own safety during her frenzied states. Nearby was the omphalos ("navel" of Earth), which was flanked by two solid gold eagles representing the authority of Zeus, and the cleft from which emerged the sacred pneuma.

Rites of the Consultant:
It is not that you went to the Delphi, placed yourself in a "Q" and when you get the chance to meet the Oracle, you asked her to answer your question and then returned home with that she Prophesied. Actually, to get an answer, the supplicant [consultant] to the oracle would undergo a four-stage process, that is typical of shamanic journeys.

Step 1: Journey to Delphi — Supplicants were motivated by some need to undertake the long and sometimes arduous journey to come to Delphi in order to consult the oracle. This journey was motivated by an awareness of the existence of the oracle, the growing motivation on the part of the individual or group to undertake the journey, and the gathering of information about the oracle as providing answers to important questions.

Step 2: Preparation of the Supplicant — Supplicants were interviewed in preparation of their presentation to the Oracle, by the priests in attendance. The genuine cases were sorted and the supplicant had to go through rituals involving the framing of their questions, the presentation of gifts to the Oracle and a procession along the Sacred Way carrying laurel leaves to visit the temple, symbolic of the journey they had made.

Step 3: Visit to the Oracle — The supplicant would then be led into the temple to visit the adytum, put his question to the Pythia, receive his answer and depart. The degree of preparation already undergone would mean that the supplicant was already in a very aroused and meditative state, similar to the shamanic journey elaborated on in the article.

Step 4: Return Home — Oracles were meant to give the advice to shape future action, that was meant to be implemented by the supplicant, or by those that had sponsored the supplicant to visit the Oracle.

It should be noted that the validity of the Oracular utterance was confirmed by the consequences of the application of the oracle to the lives of those people who sought Oracular guidance.

Oracular Procedure:
Inquiries could only be made of Apollo once a year on the seventh day of the Greek month of Bysios-Apollo’s birthday. However, according to Plutarch, this was eventually changed to the seventh day of each month except the winter months when Apollo did not reside in Delphi. The change from yearly inquiries to monthly was made no later than 480 BCE. Obviously many people wanted to consult the oracle. So, at a time, it needs to appoint three oracles, which we already explained earlier.

To organize the people and communities that wished to visit the oracle on the given day precedence was given. The city of Delphi always received the first precedence and bequeathed second place to a city of their choosing. Those without precedence drew lots for the place. Unfortunately, those at the end of the line may not have gotten a chance to see the Oracle because of the setting sun and would then have to wait until the next month to try again.  Similarly, despite the precedence system, any person could consult the oracle as long as they made an offering to Apollo according to their means -[Parke, 19-22].

Petitioners drew lots to determine the order of admission, but representatives of a city-state or those who brought larger donations to Apollo were secured a higher place in line. Each person approaching the Oracle was accompanied with a proxenos specific to the state of the petitioner, whose job was to identify the citizen of their polis. This service too was paid for.

Consultants, carrying laurel branches sacred to Apollo, approached the temple along the winding upward course of the Sacred Way, bringing a young goat kid for sacrifice in the forecourt of the temple, and a monetary fee.

Carved into the entrance of the temple were two phrases, which seem to have played an important part in the later temple ritual: γνῶθι σεαυτόν ("know thyself") and μηδὲν ἄγαν ("nothing in excess"), and an enigmatic "E".

What is "E at Delphi"?
According to Plutarch, —As the first letter of ἐγγύα πάρα δ'ἄτα ("make a pledge and mischief is nigh"), In ancient times, the origin of these phrases was attributed to one or more of the Seven Sages of Greece. And, Michael Barkas explains as-

“The third Delphic maxim functions argumentatively (or dialectically) with the other two and constitutes the ALL. If one affirms that they possess the "know thyself" along with the "nothing in excess", then at the same time the "pledge and mischief is nigh" is committed. The third exists for the other two; without the third maxim, the other two do not complete the circle, whereas the third one constitutes its beginning and its end. The tragicality of the three Delphic maxims reveals the GAME that takes place in Delphi, in the Earth's Navel that philosophically can be compared with the Socratic Ignorance, poetically with the Blindness of Oedipus and scientifically with the Uncertainty Principle.”

However, what we are telling, at the temple fire to Hestia, a live goat kid would be set in front of the Altar and sprinkled with water. If the kid trembled from the hooves upward it was considered a good omen for the oracle, [but if it didn't, the enquirer was considered to have been rejected by the god and the consultation was terminated]. The goat was then slaughtered and upon the sacrifice, the animal's organs, particularly its liver, were examined to ensure the signs were favorable, and then burned outside on the altar of Chios. The rising smoke was a signal that the oracle was open.

Plutarch describes this event of one session, in which, the omens were ill-favored, but the Oracle was consulted nonetheless. The priests proceeded to receive the prophecy, but the result was a hysterical uncontrollable reaction from the priestess that resulted in her death a few days later.

The Pythia seems she was into a trance like a state. And when she was ready inquirers would be led in by a priest who would ask the question. The Oracle would respond and the priests would interpret the answers for the visitor -[Oppe, 215]. Often Pytheya answers to questions would be put into hexameter by a priest.

Nevertheless, details of how the Pythia operated are missing and those who discussed the Oracle in any detail are from 1st century BC to 4th century AD and give conflicting stories.

Some account claimed that the Pythia delivered oracles in a frenzied state induced by vapors rising from a chasm in the rock and that she spoke gibberish which priests interpreted as the enigmatic prophecies and turned them into poetic dactylic hexameters preserved in Greek literature. But Joseph Fontenrose and Lisa Maurizio, who argue that the ancient sources uniformly represent the Pythia speaking intelligibly, and giving prophecies in her own voice. on the other hand, Herodotus, writing in the fifth century BC describes the Pythia speaking in dactylic hexameters.

However, before the Pythia could be questioned, she had to ritually prepare herself. Much of the purification rites involve Laurel as it is the tree of Apollo and associated with divination. The Pythia would chew laurel and bay leaves, and wear a crown of laurel while sitting on a tripod adorned with Laurel over a fissure in the cellar of the temple which is known as adytum.

Adytum is a small chamber was located below the general floor of the temple and offset to one side, perhaps constructed specifically over the crossing faults. The intimate chamber allowed the escaping vapors to be contained in quarters close enough to provoke intoxicating effects. Plutarch reports that the temple was filled with a sweet smell when the "deity" was present:

Not often nor regularly, but occasionally and fortuitously, the room in which they seat the god's consultants is filled with a fragrance and breeze as if the adytum were sending forth the essences of the sweetest and most expensive perfumes from a spring -[Plutarch, Moralia 437c].

Influence of Oracular Statement on Person, Society, and State: 
Story-1: Among the children of Israel there was a rich man, who had a beautiful daughter. The man's heir was his nephew- a vagabond. The nephew wanted to marry his cousin sister, but his uncle denied. So the nephew went to Pythia and seek advice. The Pythia told him- "Your uncle will not die soon. So if you want to marry her, you have to kill your uncle." She also instructs him how to kill and how to be safe from the accusation of the murder.

One day, the rich man was found dead near the residential area of a tribe of Bani Israel. There were many speculations regarding the motive of the murder, but nobody could figure out whodunnit.

The relatives of the rich man including his nephew started searching for the murderer. But they still could not trace the murderer. It was a law, that if anyone killed near a city and the murdered would not trace, then the city dweller will pay the blood-money. With this law, the nephew demanded the blood-money to the nearby tribe's men. But they denied, saying: "We are not the murderer." They trying to get rid of the evidence.

The incident that drew a harsh discord became into a harsh argument which made a war situation between the two tribes of the Israelis. And then a wise man said aloud, "Why you will kill each other when a Prophet of God among you? Go to him, may be he will solve this with the help of God."

So both parties came to Moses and appealed to him to resolve the dispute and by that time the possibility of resolving a dispute by making the parties give an oath has not been revealed yet. The nephew of the victim demanded revenge but his claims have been turned down due to the lack of witnesses. On the other hand, before Moses all parties were equal. 

However, there was no evidence for issuing a verdict on the matter. Moses takes some time, then he told them to slaughter a cow. And they think he is making fun of them. Actually, they always made fun of Moses, and love to bring those unsolved cases to him so that they may get rid of him with a failure from him. However, in this cases, may be it was exceptional, they politely asked him to tell God to be more specific.

Moses said, "It should be a handsome yellow cow."
There are plenty of handsome yellow cows around. Pick one and sacrifice, but no, the Jews are whiny, as they so often are, so they want Moses to tell God to tell him to tell them what specific kind of cow He wants for a sacrifice.  Because all cows look the same to them.

Hmmm, want to solve something that is out of your knowledge? Then you have to pay according to the job nature. Free things never valued, do you ever thanked God for Sunlight, Moonlight, Water, Air or the Soil that keeps you alive?

So God comes back with this list of everything he wants this special cow to be. It is now too demanding and too picky that fitted perfectly for the whiny Jews. Now details of the Cow they got, nothing to asked. So they say, “Now have you brought us the truth.” 

Here’s how the cow story went down, Qur'an says- And when ye slew a man and disagreed concerning it and Allah brought forth that which ye were hiding. -'[2:72]

When Moses said to his people: “God demands that you sacrifice a cow,”
They said: “Are you making fun of us?”
And he said: “God forbid that I be of the ignorant.”
“Call on your Lord for us,” they said, “that He might inform us what kind she should be.” 
“Neither old nor young says God, but of age in between,” answered Moses. “So do as you are bid.”
“Call on your Lord,” they said, “to tell us the color of the cow.”
“God says,” answered Moses, “a fawn colored cow, rich yellow, well pleasing to the eye.”
“Call on your Lord,” they said, “to name its variety, as cows are all alike to us. If God wills we shall be guided aright.”
And Moses said: “He says it’s a cow unyoked, nor worn out by plowing or watering the fields, one in good shape with no mark or blemish.” 
“Now have you brought us the truth,” they said; -[2:67-71]

The Jews went out in search of such a cow. The only one that matched the description was the one owned by the orphaned youth. They met him on the way and asked the price for which he would sell his cow. He told them he would have to consult his mother first, so they accompanied him to his house and offered her three gold coins. She refused their offer, saying that the cow was worth much more.

They went on increasing their offer and the mother kept on refusing. Finally, they urged the son not to speak to his mother and to be reasonable. He told them: "I will not sell the cow without my mother's approval, even if you offered me its skin filled with gold!"
On hearing this, his mother smiled and said: "Let that be the price: its skin filled with gold."
They realized that no other cow would do; they had to have it at any price. They agreed to buy the cow and paid with its skin filled with gold.

They brought the cow to Moses and sacrificed. Then God commanded that the victim should be touched by a part of the cow’s body.

What happened then?
Wow. Just wow.  Imagine if all of this actually happened. You’d have all these Jews slapping a corpse with bloody chunks of beef, but since there is no God and since people do not come back from the dead, nothing happens. So they do it, but it happened.
What happened?
Oh ha, the miracle happened, the dead guy comes back to life temporarily to reveal the killer. He [the dead man] pronounced: “I was killed by my nephew.” Qur'an says- And We said: Smite him with some of it. Thus Allah bringeth the dead to life and showeth you His portents so that ye may understand. -'[2:73]

Now we will see what the Jewish Sacred books said to this special heifer. According to Jewish tradition, a "Red Heifer" [The yellow cow, is basically the same as the red cow of the Bible. The Jew make it red or God just forgot the color??, we do not know what the Jew would comment about this.] is a female cow that is three years of age with a particular reddish hue and cannot have even two hairs of any other color. It cannot be used for any type of labor and must be blemish free. The biblical commandment regarding the Red Heifer can be found in the Book of Numbers and is considered as the only antidote to the state of impurity brought on by death.

“The emergence of the red heifer is not some mystical miracle,” elucidated Rabbi Richman. “It is a practical development alongside Torah knowledge and science.”
The Red Heifer (Hebrew: פָרָ֨ה אֲדֻמָּ֜ה‎‎; para adumma), also known as the red cow, was a cow brought to the priests as a sacrifice according to the Hebrew Bible, and its ashes were used for the ritual purification of Tum'at HaMet ("the impurity of the dead"), that is, an Israelite who had come into contact with a corpse.

What happened then?
Oh ha, after pronounced his murderer’s name the dead became silent again. And the Jews killed the nephew according to the law of God and from then nephews lost their inheritance from their uncle.

Story-2: Abdul Muttalib, the grand father of Muhammad, the last Prophet. He engaged himself finding the disappeared Zamzam Well influenced by his dream. And in search of the well, he engaged himself on finding works in between the mountain Safa and Marwa with the help of his son Haris. The job was difficult and too laborious. So he seeks the cooperation of Quraish. But they were not interested to co-operate as they thought it’s an impossible work and their efforts will go in vain. So Abdul Muttalib promised that if he able to find the well and God gives him 10 (ten) sons, then he will sacrifice a son in the name of God.

Later Abdul Muttalib achieved 10 (ten) sons. And after a long effort, he finds the well with the help of his son Haris. Then the father and son both were dug it together.

Abdul Muttalib- this honored head of the family promised to sacrifice a son to the name of God. So he called all of his sons and reminds them of his promise. All of the sons agreed with his father to fulfill his promise. So Abdul Muttalib draws lottery on his 10 (ten) sons. And the lottery result shows the name of his most beloved son Abdullah. So he decided to sacrifice him.

On the particular date, people were assembled on the premises of Ka'ba to celebrate the sacrifice. But it was interrupted for the 1st time by the mother’s side of Abdullah. Then others from the gathering requested to abstain himself from this sacrifice. So Abdul Muttalib goes to Pythia for her ruling. There were 360 gods and goddess placed inside Ka'ba for worship, one a day of the Moon Year. Pythia was widely credited for her prophecies ie if someone expresses his desire to god while standing in a specified place of Ka'ba, he was answered. Thus it was said to Abdul Muttalib to draw a lottery between 10 (ten) camels and his son and if the result is camel then he should sacrifice them. But if the result is his son, then he should continue the lottery adding 10 (ten) camels with the previous till the desired result. Thus on the 10th draw of the lottery ie when the lottery draws between 100 (hundred) camels and his son Abdullah, he gets the desired result ie. 100 camels.

From that period, the price of human life (Blood Money) to be 100 (hundred) camels was the common practice. Till then, this system is defined as the law and was pursued after the Prophethood of Muhammad.

Story-3: In 560 BC, Croesus of Lydia, in a trial of oracles, consulted all the famous oracles as to what he was doing on an appointed day. According to Herodotus, the Oracle proclaimed:

"I count the grains of sand on the beach and measure the sea; I understand the speech of the dumb and hear the voiceless. The smell has come to my sense of a hard shelled tortoise boiling and bubbling with a lamb's flesh in a bronze pot: the cauldron underneath it is of bronze, and bronze is the lid."

Delphi was declared the winner. Croesus then asked if he should make war on the Persians and if he should take to himself any allied force. The oracles to whom he sent this question included those at Delphi and Thebes. Both oracles gave the same response, that if Croesus made war on the Persians, he would destroy a mighty empire. They further advised him to seek out the most powerful Greek peoples and make an alliance with them.
Croesus paid a high fee to the Delphians and then sent to the Oracle asking "Would his monarchy last long?" The Pythia answered:

"Whenever a mule shall become sovereign king of the Medians, then, Lydian Delicate-Foot, flee by the stone-strewn Hermus, flee, and think not to stand fast, nor shame to be chicken-hearted."

Croesus thought it impossible that a mule should be king of the Medes and thus believed that he and his issue would never be out of power. He thus decided to make common cause with certain Greek city states and attack Persia.

However, it was he, not the Persians, who was defeated, fulfilling the prophecy but not his interpretation of it. He apparently forgot that Cyrus, the victor, was half Mede (by his mother), half Persian (by his father) and therefore could be considered a mule.

Some Oracular Statements:
Pythia was the priestess presiding over the Oracle of Apollo at Delphi. There are more than 500 supposed Oracular statements which have survived from various sources referring to the oracle at Delphi. Many are anecdotal and have survived as proverbs. Several are ambiguously phrased, apparently in order to show the Oracle in a good light regardless of the outcome. Such prophesies were admired for their dexterity of phrasing. One such famous prediction was the answer to an unknown person who was inquiring as to whether it would be safe for him to join a military campaign; the answer was: "Go, return not die in war", which can have two entirely opposite meanings, depending on where a missing comma is supposed to be – before or after the word "not". Nevertheless, the Oracle seems consistent to have advocated peaceful, not violent courses generally. The following list presents some of the most prominent and historically significant prophecies of Delphi.

480 BCE
When Xerxes, the son of Darius the Great of Persia, returned to finish the job of conquering the Greeks in which his father had failed, the Athenians consulted the oracle. They were told:

Now your statues are standing and pouring sweat. They shiver with dread. The black blood drips from the highest rooftops. They have seen the necessity of evil. Get out, get out of my sanctum and drown your spirits in woe.

It was unambiguous. When persuaded to seek advice a second time, the oracle gave a way for the Athenians to escape their doom. When Athena approached her father to help her city, Zeus responded that he would grant that "a wall of wood alone shall be uncaptured, a boon to you and your children."

The Oracle again advised the Athenians to flee: Await not in quiet the coming of the horses, the marching feet, the armed host upon the land. Slip away. Turn your back. You will meet in battle anyway. O holy Salamis, you will be the death of many a woman's son between the seedtime and the harvest of the grain.

Meanwhile, the Spartans also consulted the oracle and were told: The strength of bulls or lions cannot stop the foe. No, he will not leave off, I say until he tears the city or the king limb from limb.
or in a version according to Herodotus:

Hear your fate, O dwellers in Sparta of the wide spaces;
Either your famed, great town must be sacked by Perseus' sons,
Or, if that be not, the whole land of Lacedaemon
Shall mourn the death of a king of the house of Heracles,
For not the strength of lions or of bulls shall hold him,
Strength against strength; for he has the power of Zeus,
And will not be checked until one of these two he has consumed.

The Spartans withdrew in consternation, wondering which fate was worse. The Delphians themselves then asked how Persia could be defeated. The oracle replied: Pray to the Winds. They will prove to be mighty allies of Greece.

Events overtook the prophecy when the Persian army assaulted Thermopylae, where a Spartan-led coalition (popularly called the "300" after the number of Spartans sent (who were, excepting one man with an eye infection, killed to a man)) and allies held the pass against them. The Spartans under King Leonidas resisted the Persian advance at Thermopylae until betrayed by treachery. Refusing to retreat, the entire Spartan contingent, including their King (as foretold), lost their lives, but in so doing gained immortal fame. The Persian armada then sailed to nearby Cape Artemisium, where they were met by the Athenian fleet. The Athenian ships fought against great odds, but in three battles managed to hold their own.

A tremendous storm then arose at Artemisium, with the most violent winds attacking the ships for three days. The Persians lost about 20% of their warships and perhaps the same number of transport vessels to the storm. The stormy winds and huge waves did not harm the Athenian ships.

Back in Athens Themistocles argued that the wall of wood referred to the Athenian navy and persuaded the Athenians to pursue their policy of using wealth from their Attic silver mines at Laurium to continue building their fleet. On the grounds that the Oracle referred to the nearby island of Salamis as "holy", he claimed that those slain would be Greece's enemies, not the Athenians. For these, the oracle would have said "O cruel Salamis". His voice carried the day, Athens was evacuated to Salamis and in a following naval battle, the Athenian fleet and its allies destroyed the Persian fleet at Salamis, while watched by Xerxes. Despite the fact that Athens was burned by the Persians, her occupants were saved, the Persian threat was ended and the authority of the Oracle was never higher.

440 BCE:
A friend of Socrates, Chaerephon, went before Pythia asking, "Is there any man alive wiser than Socrates?"
The answer that he received was simply, "None."

431 BCE:
At the outbreak of the Peloponnesian War, the Spartans send a delegation to Delphi inquire whether it would be wise to go to war against Athens. According to Thucydides, "It is said that the god replied that if they fought with all their might, victory would be theirs and that he himself would be on their side, whether they invoked him or not."

403 BCE:
Lysander, the Spartan victor of the Peloponnesian War was warned to beware: Also the dragon (serpent), earthborn, in craftiness coming behind thee.

He was slain from behind in 395 BC by Neachorus, who had a serpent painted upon his shield.

401 BCE:
Sparta warned:
Sure though thy feet, proud Sparta, have a care,
A lame king's reign may see thee trip — Beware!
Troubles unlooked for long shall vex thy shore,
And rolling Time his tide of carnage pour.

Agesilaus, the lame king of Sparta, who acceded to the Spartan throne at the time of Lysander, through attacking enemies in every quarter, lost control of the seas to the Persians who attacked Spartan coastal locations. In his obsession with Thebes, he incited the Thebans under Epaminondas to fight back. The Spartans were defeated for the first time by the Thebans in the battle of Leuctra in 371 BC; this led to the invasion of Sparta itself and its defeat at the battle of Mantinea in 362 BC.

359 BCE:
Philip II of Macedon consulted the Oracle and was told: "With silver spears, you may conquer the world"

The king then sought to control the silver mines in the neighboring Thracian and Illyrian kingdom and using them to bribe his way to early victories, playing one Greek state off against the others, and isolating his enemies by bribes to potential allies.

Philip also had a highly spirited black colt that no one could ride. The Oracle of Delphi stated whoever could ride this horse would conquer the world, but despite many attempts, neither Philip nor any of his generals could mount the horse. His son, Alexander, later to be called the Great, succeeded as he realized that the horse was afraid of his own shadow. Philip gave the horse Bucephalus to Alexander, who took the steed on his conquest of Asia.

336 BCE:
Alexander the Great visited the Delphic Oracle wishing to hear a prophecy that he would soon conquer the entire ancient world. To his surprise, the Oracle refused a direct comment and asked him to come later. Furious, Alexander dragged Pythia by the hair out of the chamber until she screamed: "You are invincible, my son!"
The moment he heard these words he dropped her, saying, "Now I have my answer".

279 BCE:
Plundered by a Celtic invasion, the Oracle declared: "Care for these things fall on me!"

The Celts were met by earthquakes, avalanches, and a massive snow storm, forcing them to retreat. But the Romans were a different matter.

83 BC:
Delphi was razed by an attack from the Thracian tribe of Maedi who extinguished the sacred fire which had been burning uninterrupted for centuries. At the time of Pompey the Great, Cicero, Pompey's ally, consulted the Oracle as to how he should find the greatest fame and was told: "Make your own nature, not the advice of others, your guide in life."

Pompey was subsequently defeated by Julius Caesar. Cicero cultivated his oratory and his skills in the courts in preserving Rome from the Catilinarian conspiracy, earning undying fame.

67 CE:
Emperor Nero, who was just 30 years old and had killed his own mother in 59 AD, when visiting the Oracle was told: "Your presence here outrages the god you seek. Go back, matricide! The number 73 marks the hour of your downfall!"

He was angered and had the Pythia burned alive. Nero thought he would have a long reign and die at 73. Instead, his reign came to a short end after a revolt by Galba who was 73 years of age at the time.

362 CE:
On behalf of his emperor Julian the Apostate, Oribasius visited the Delphic oracle, now in a rather desolate state, offering his emperor's services to the temple and, in return, receiving one of the last prophecies by the Delphic Pythia-

"Tell the emperor that my hall has fallen to the ground. Phoibos no longer has his house, nor his mantic bay, nor his prophetic spring; the water has dried up."

Conclusion:
What to say in the conclusion? We are now living in the 21st Century, an era of Science and Technology, and we do not believe in gods, yet we have the historical information that-

Between 535 and 615 BCE, the Oracles of Delphi are known to have survived, of which over half are said to be accurate historically.

Thus we need to have a scientific proof or Logical explanation [if any] of the Question- "How did Pythia be Inspired to Receive a Prophecy?"

The Temple at Delphi stationed from 1400 BCE to 381 CE and the question may be as older as her long tenure. Previously, it was debated, whether the Oracle received the words from Apollo by Spiritual Inspiration or by hallucination [Resultant of her drinking waters of the Cassotis, by the sacred pneuma. which emerged through the cleft under the Triad and due to the laurel and bay leaves that she chewed.] or that is purely a suggestion.

And, in the twentieth century, the reasoning for the Pythia’s riddled answers and the nature of the vapors rising from the floor of the temple again has been richly debated.

Early research believed there to be no vapors or chasms below the temple, despite descriptions in ancient texts. New research shows that there are two definite fault lines intersecting below the temple. The Delphic Fault runs east to west and the Kerna Fault runs north and south. Analysis of the hydrocarbon gases in the spring water near the temple are shown to contain ethylene which is sweet smelling and if rising into an enclosed chamber would have been potent enough to cause a trance state (Roach).

Today the concentration of gasses is weaker because of the absence of seismic activity to push the gasses to the surface. Some People believed that the earthquake that damaged the temple in 373 BCE. closed the fissures that were releasing the gasses.

The Oracle's last response in 362 BCE. states that “the temple has fallen” and as Christianity gained power she states that it was interrupting the flow of divine power from Apollo (Hale). Some People of this day believe that the Pythia lost power not only because of the rise of Christianity but also because she lacked the hallucinogens necessary to prophesy.

'A Hebrew boy, a god who rules among the blessed,
Bids me leave this house forward and go back to Hades.
So in silence go from my altars.'

The End.
Not Yet Justified.

# Someone asked me, "Bro, is there any basis to believe in Pythian Prophecy?"
@ I said, "You know, people come to Pythia, with their Question that Human unable to answer. And the record says- Between 535 and 615 BCE, the Oracles of Delphi are known to have survived, of which over half are said to be accurate historically.

We Muslims are instructed not to consult with Palmist, Soothsayer or Pythia, even we do not believe in gods, but we believe in Pythian Prophecy, that is sometimes it may true, because we know how Oracle works. It is said in the Qur'an-

And there were men from mankind who sought refuge in men from the Jinns, so they [only] increased them in burden. ...... And we have sought [to reach] the heaven but found it filled with powerful guards and burning flames. And we used to sit therein in positions for hearing, but whoever listens now will find a burning flame lying in wait for him.-[72:6–9]

The rationalists generally sought an explanation regarding Pythia’s abilities. Even we found, from the earlier, there was a process of abjection to eject Pythia from her privileged place, employing that, she was deified, she was demonized, she was sexualized, she was defeminized, she was made ignorant, and she was transcribed and prescribed and proscribed by Priests, etc, yet the truth is, her Position in the society never decline throughout the ages.

However, the toxic vapor is a factor. It may possible when Pythia was in her "high" on it, she infused with the spirit of the devils.

The early fathers of the Christian church could not think of any explanation for the oracular Prophecy, but that demons were allowed to assist them to spread idolatry; so that the need for a Savior would be more evident." 

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.

Sources:
http://www.coastal.edu/intranet/ashes2art/delphi2/misc-essays/oracle_of_delphi.html
Homeric Hymn to Apollo 363–369.
Morgan C. 1990, Athletes and Oracles: The Transformation of Olympia and Delphi in the Eighth Century BC;  p. 148.
Michael Scott, Delphi: A History of the Center of the Ancient World;  p. 30, 11
Lewis Farnell, The Cults of the Greek States, 1907, vol. IV, p.189.
Maurizio 2001, pp. 38–54.
Herodotus. The Histories. Godley, A. D., translator. Harvard University Press. 1920. Book one, chapter 65. (1922)
Deitrich, Bernard C. (1992), "Divine Madness and Conflict at Delphi" (Kernos 5) PDF at https://scholar.google.com/scholar? see discussion.
Fontenrose, J. (1978) "Python. A Study of Delphic Myth and Its Origins, (Berkeley),  pp. 196–227;
Fontenrose, J, (1981), "Delphic Oracle: Its Responses and Operations".
Forrest, W.G. (1957), "Colonisation and the Rise of Delphi", pp. 160–175)
M. Chappell, "Delphi and the Homeric Hymn to Apollo", Classical Quarterly 56 (2006:331-48)
Diodorus Siculus 16.26.1–4.
William J. Broad, The Oracle: The Lost Secrets and Hidden Message of Ancient Delphi. (New York: Penguin) 2006.2007, p.21.p.30-40.
Metamorphoses i. 321, iv. 642;
D. S. Robertson, "The Delphian Succession in the Opening of the Eumenides" The Classical Review 55. 2 (September 1941, pp. 69–70) p. 69,

H.W. Parke and D.E.W. Wormell The Delphic oracle, 1956 Volume 1:
Herbert B. Huffman, "The Oracular Process: Delphi and the Near East" Vetus Testamentum 57.4, (2007:449–60).
Plutarch Moralia 414b.
"Plutarch • On the Failure of Oracles". Penelope.uchicago.edu. Retrieved 2012-03-19.
Bowden 2005, pp. 15–16;
Vandenberg, Phillip, (2007) "Mysteries of the Oracles

Hodge, A. Trevor. "The Mystery of Apollo's E at Delphi," American Journal of Archaeology, Vol. 85, No. 1. (Jan., 1981), pp. 83–84.
Plato, Charmides 164d–165a.
Plato, Protagoras 343a–b.
Jon D. (2011). Ancient Greek Religion. John Wiley & Sons. p. 99. ISBN 978-1-4443-5819-3.
Godwin 1876, p. 12.
http://www.wisecounselresearch.com/research/portrait-gallery/delphic-oracle sighted 14/5/2013
Fontenrose, Joseph (1981), "Delphic Oracle: Its Responses and Operations".
Temple of Apollo at Delphi, Ancient-Greece.org
J.Z. De Boer, and J. R. Hale. “The Geological Origins of the Oracle of Delphi, Greece,”  2000.

Herodotus, The Histories, at the Perseus Project
Pausanias, Description of Greece, (ed. and translated with commentary by Sir James Frazer), 1913 edition. Cf. v.5
Plutarch, De defectu oraculorum ("On the Decline of Oracles") and De Pythiae Oraculis ("On the Oracles of the Pythia"), in Moralia, vol. 5 (Loeb Library, Harvard University Press)

de Boer, Jelle Zeilinga, John Rigby Hale & Henry A. Spiller, "The Delphic Oracle: A Multidisciplinary Defense of the Gaseous Vent Theory." Clinical Toxicology 40.2 189–196 (2000)
de Boer, Jelle Zeilinga, Jeffrey P. Chandon & John Rigby Hale, "New Evidence for the Geological Origins of the Ancient Delphic Oracle," Geology 29.8, 707–711 (2001)
de Boer, Jelle Zeilinga, Jeffrey P. Chandon, John Rigby Hale & Henry A. Spiller, "Questioning the Delphic Oracle", Scientific American (August 2003)
Bouché-Leclercq, Auguste, Histoire de la divination dans l'Antiquité, volumes I-IV, Paris (1879–1882)
Bowden, Hugh (2005). Classical Athens and the Delphic Oracle: Divination and Democracy. Cambridge University Press. ISBN 0-521-53081-4.
Broad, William J. The Oracle: Ancient Delphi and the Science Behind Its Lost Secrets, New York, Penguin Press, ISBN 978-0-14-303859-7 (2007);

Connelly, Joan Breton Portrait of a Priestess: Women and Ritual in Ancient Greece, Princeton University Press, 2007, ISBN 0-691-12746-8
Dempsey, T., Reverend, The Delphic oracle, its early history, influence and fall, Oxford, B.H. Blackwell (1918)

Farnell, Lewis Richard, The Cults of the Greek States, Volumes I-V, Clarendon Press, (1896–1909); cf. especially, volume IV on the Pythoness and Delphi
Fontenrose, Joseph Eddy, Python; a study of Delphic myth and its origins, New York, Biblio;Tannen, ISBN 0-8196-0285-X (1959; 1974)
Fontenrose, Joseph Eddy, The Delphic oracle, its responses and operations, with a catalogue of responses, Berkeley : University of California Press, ISBN 0-520-03360-4 (1978)
Foster J., Lehoux D.R., "The Delphic Oracle and the ethylene-intoxication hypothesis", Clinical Toxicology, 45, 85–89 (2007)
Golding, William, The Double Tongue, London, Faber (1995). Posthumous, fictional novel by the Nobel prize winner about a Pythia in the 1st century BCE.
Goodrich, Norma Lorre, Priestesses, New York : F. Watts, ISBN 0-531-15113-1 (1989); Harper Collins, Perennial, ISBN 0-06-097316-1 (1990)
Guthrie, William Keith Chambers, The Greeks and their Gods (1950)
Hall, Manly Palmer, The Secret Teachings of All Ages, Cf Chapter 14, (1928)
Harissis H.V. 2015. “A Bittersweet Story: The True Nature of the Laurel of the Oracle of Delphi”
Holland, Leicester B., "The Mantic Mechanism at Delphi," American Journal of Archaeology 37 pp. 201–214 (1933)
Lehoux D.R., "Drugs and the Delphic Oracle", Classical World, 101, 1, 41–56 (2007)
Maurizio, Lisa, (2001) "The Voice at the Centre of the World: The Pythia's Ambiguity and Authority" pp. 46–50
Mikalson, Jon D. (2005.) Ancient Greek Religion. Blackwell Ancient Religions.
Mitford, William, The History of Greece (1784); Cf. v.1, Chapter III, Section 2, p. 177, "Origin and Progress of the Oracles"

Parke, Herbert William,  (1939), A History of the Delphic Oracle, Basil Blackwell, Oxford, ASIN B002NZWT0Y
Parke, Herbert William, (r1992) Sibyls and Sibylline Prophecy in Classical Antiquity, Routledge, London, ISBN 978-0-415-07638-8
Piccardi, Luigi, (2000), "Active faulting at Delphi: seismotectonic remarks and a hypothesis for the geological environment of a myth", Geology, 28, 651–654
Potter, David Stone,  (1990), Prophecy and history in the crisis of the Roman Empire: a historical commentary on the Thirteenth Sibylline Oracle, Cf. Chapter 3
Rohde, Erwin, Psyche: (1925) The Cult of Souls and the Belief in Immortality among the Greeks, trans. by W. B. Hillis,
West, Martin Litchfield, The Orphic Poems, Oxford: Clarendon Press ISBN 0-19-814854-2 (1983)